GP wades into 'difficult' Archie Battersbee case 'Science can't tell us what's right'


Share post:


The 12-year-old’s family confirmed on Saturday afternoon Archie had died following his life support and treatment ceasing at 10am. Hollie Dance and Paul Battersbee were told on Friday treatment for Archie will be withdrawn after they made a last-ditch appeal to the European Court of Human Rights on Friday night to intervene. The case has caused controversy across the UK, with ethical questions being raised. GP Dr Josh Parker appeared on Sunday’s BBC Breakfast to discuss the case, where he spoke about both sides of the debate and stated: “Science can’t tell us what’s right” when it comes to emotional situations such as Archie’s.

When asked about the process medical staff will have taken regarding Archie, he replied: “The first thing to say is this absolutely isn’t the kind of decision that one doctor would just make on their own.

“Usually, there will come a point where the team are starting to think that the prognosis is looking very poor – that there isn’t going to be an outcome that’s considered to be good.

“And so, then a process of trying to make sure that we’re certain about that, that we’re convinced that that really is the truth of the fact, then there’s a conversation with the rest of the team.”

He explained pediatric intensive care involves a huge amount of specialists.

READ MORE: Emmerdale theory: Marlon Dingle to die as Paddy Kirk makes discovery

Talking about how the family is involved, he added that there’s a process in the conversation, which starts early.

“Ultimately, what you’re looking for is a consensus,” he commented.

BBC host Nina Warhurst remarked: “And the hope, I suppose, is that a consensus is reached and it does not have to be escalated.

“When it does, and it becomes a legal procedure, that’s really difficult for the judiciary, isn’t it?”

“Definitely it raises difficult questions,” the GP agreed.

“Absolutely, it raises really fundamental questions,” the GP answered.

“But the law’s got a series of cases from the past that it can rely on to help answer these questions about what’s in somebody’s best interests, as well as the expertise of specialists around the country who can go through the medical facts of the case and explain the prognosis – ‘Is this person brainstem dead? How have we come to that conclusion?’ and sort of taking things from there.”

Presenter Ben Thompson pointed out: “Of course, the dilemma in all of this is whilst there might be scientific or medical evidence, in all of these cases there is a huge amount of emotion, and that sort of clouds the judgment somewhat, even though it is a fundamental part of those decisions.”

“Yeah, absolutely,” Doctor Parker agreed. “So, in terms of the facts or science of it, that can’t answer the question for you.

“Only human values can answer that, only ethics, only what we believe is right and wrong.

“The science itself can’t tell us what’s good, it can’t tell us what’s right.

“And the whole project of ethics is fundamentally human.

“It will raise difficult emotions, and part of the skill for the doctors and the medical team is moderating those emotions and using them to help make a good decision.”

Archie was found unconscious at his home in April, and doctors said it was highly likely he was brain stem dead and that recovery wouldn’t be possible.

His family disagreed and fought the hospital trust team through the courts. Judges agreed life support should be withdrawn.

BBC Breakfast airs daily from 6am on BBC One.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

Selena Gomez, 30, says ‘I’m a little big’ as she hits back at Golden Globe outfit trolls

Selena, 30, hit back at online trolls who wrote nasty comments about her weight, despite oozing confidence...

Dancing On Ice’s Ekin-Su details ‘supportive’ gestures from partner Davide

“It's great, I’m happy I’m doing it, no regrets at all, see you later to the curse!”Ekin...

Kate wore stunning full length gown with a trendy twist – shows off her enviable legs

The royal turned heads in a silver chain with lots of geometric shapes attached to it, and...

Nick Kyrgios risks trouble with Aussie police after scooter ride before Australian Open

Nick Kyrgios could find himself in hot water ahead of the Australian Open after he was pictured riding an e-scooter...